Your next stop for a slice is actually inside your subway stop! See No Evil Pizza hails from accredited Chef Ed Carew, previously of Fiamma and Gramercy Tavern, and mastermind Adrian Gallo, behind Nothing Really Matters (one of our favorite hidden bars in the city) and coffeeshop Tiny Dancer. And just like Gallo’s other joints, this new pizzeria is tucked away in the 50th Street subway station.
Neapolitan pizza meets a New York slice here, topped with the finest house-made and farm fresh ingredients. The menu serves a selection of stuzzichini (Italian appetizers), antipasti and pizza.
Menu highlights include Cremini balsamic braised mushrooms with crispy sage leaves, Toast alla Veloce with fresh sardines, caper-mint salsa,mozzarella, fresno, and polenta bread, and their Hell Pie which is smothered with sauce, hot soppressata, pepperoni, hot coppa, scamorza, pecorino, and calabrian chili.
For drinks, you can choose from their lambrusco selection, frozen Evil Sangria, No Negroni Sbagliato, beer and more. If you want to keep drinking be sure to carry the party over to Nothing Really Matters next store.
And of course, if you want to opt for a non-alcoholic beverage See No Evil Pizza has those too. Or, you could pop by the neighboring aforementioned coffee shop, Tiny Dancer.
Studio & Projects’ Little Wing Lee brought the design of the unique venue to life that was formerly an abandoned Dunkin Donuts. Taking influence from its Times Square location, the space reignites the era feel of the New York punk scene in the 1970’s and 80’s. However, the real show stoppers are the three state-of-the-art electric Marra Forni pizza ovens that bring you all that delicious flavor.
Dinner service is available Monday through Saturday from 5pm to midnight, so it makes the perfect place to grab food on your commute home or after a Broadway show! Make your reservation today through Resy.