Welcome to September, New York City!
Are you ready to trade rooftop parties for cozy autumn nights?
This month’s lineup is seriously stacked. Whether you are craving a heavy dose of nostalgia, a psychological indie thriller, or a massive blockbuster epic, there is something hitting the big screen for every vibe.
Here are the absolute best new movies to catch in NYC theaters this September.
By Any Means (September 4)
What it’s about: This gritty action-thriller throws you straight into the criminal underworld with an adrenaline-pumping storyline of survival and impossible choices.
Why we recommend: Starring Yahya Abdul-Mateen II and Mark Wahlberg, you can expect non-stop action, sharp twists, and the kind of explosive on-screen chemistry that’s made for a weekend popcorn run.
The Salt Path (September 4)
What it’s about: A profoundly moving drama that follows a couple navigating sudden loss and rediscovering life while trekking a grueling, windswept coastline.
Why we recommend: Led by Gillian Anderson and Jason Isaacs, this is the quiet indie gem of the month. It is emotionally resonant and perfect for when you want a story that truly sticks with you after the credits roll.
Practical Magic 2 (September 11)
What it’s about: The Owens sisters are officially back. Twenty-five years after the original, a new generation’s dark abilities plunge the family into a magical crisis, forcing them to confront an ancient ancestral curse.
Why we recommend: It is the ultimate nostalgic reunion. With Sandra Bullock and Nicole Kidman returning as Sally and Gillian, this spellbinding fantasy is exactly what you need to kick off the spooky season early.
The Uprising (September 11)
What it’s about: A sweeping historical drama chronicling a massive rebellion, where ordinary people risk absolutely everything to challenge a formidable and oppressive empire.
Why we recommend: When you combine Andrew Garfield and Jamie Bell in a grand historical epic, you are guaranteed incredible performances and breathtaking cinematography that demands a massive screen.
Resident Evil (September 18)
What it’s about: A brutal, terrifying sci-fi horror return to the iconic video game franchise, where a new set of survivors must face an unleashing of terrifying bio-weapons.
Why we recommend: If you love edge-of-your-seat scares, this fresh take starring Austin Abrams and Paul Walter Hauser promises to lean hard into the horror. It makes for a perfectly thrilling late-night watch.
Heart of the Beast (September 25)
What it’s about: A high-stakes adventure that plunges a grizzled protagonist into an unforgiving wilderness to confront both a physical monster and his own inner demons.
Why we recommend: It is an epic showcase for Brad Pitt and J.K. Simmons. Expect incredible tension, gorgeous sweeping landscapes, and the kind of powerhouse acting that commands a packed theater.
Primetime (September 25)
What it’s about: A psychological crime thriller following a highly tense, dramatized look behind the scenes of a groundbreaking, real-life 2000s TV news segment.
Why we recommend: With Robert Pattinson starring and the powerhouse A24 behind the lens, this buzzy film is easily one of the most anticipated releases of the year. Get ready for some serious awards-season chatter.
Victorian Psycho (September 25)
What it’s about: A blood-splattered, pitch-black comedy that blends polite 19th-century society manners with absolute, unhinged slasher chaos.
Why we recommend: Maika Monroe and Jason Isaacs leading a wildly weird horror-comedy? Yes, please. It is strange, it is stylish, and it is the exact kind of offbeat cinema that makes for a wildly fun night out.
Want to keep up with the latest in the film world? We’ve got you covered! See our very own Secret Film Club for more indie recommendations and events happening across the five boroughs.