Though NYC’s iconic Magnolia Bakery (which just changed its logo!) has tons of tasty delights, no treat is quite as cherished as its creamy Banana Pudding.
Its classic flavor is beloved of course, but they also offer changing specialty flavors each month, and occasionally it takes another form…
From Friday, April 29 through this Sunday, May 8, New Yorkers (as well as those in Chicago and L.A.) have access to a rare *new* Banana Pudding Cookie! The secret menu item can only be ordered by those who know to ask, which now thanks to us, you do!
Like their pudding, the cookie is soft, chewy and full of flavor, and there are only 50-60 being made each day ($3.70 per cookie) — so make you get there early to enjoy.
Stay tuned for other secret menu items when they are announced.
See the full list of Magnolia Bakery NYC store locations here.