With a population of just 4,417 residents, this hidden gem completely trades skyscrapers for Victorian homes, antique shops, and yacht clubs.
It is the ultimate laid-back seaside escape, and you don’t even have to leave the five boroughs to experience it.
A slice of 19th-century nautical history
You really do not need to drive hours to New England to get that maritime feel. Up until you cross the bridge from Pelham Bay Park, it is all typical city scenery. But once you arrive, the urban landscape melts into a nostalgic 19th-century nautical haven.
Locals here are fiercely proud of their unique island roots. In fact, if you were actually born on the island, you are affectionately known in the community as a “clam digger.” If you moved there from somewhere else? You are a “mussel sucker.”
Stroll down City Island Avenue to take in the charming old-fashioned antique stores, local galleries, and aging storefronts that give the neighborhood its distinct character.
Feasting on fresh seafood and local charm
Most visitors flock to City Island for one major reason: the incredible food. The main drag and the southern waterfront at Belden Point are packed with fantastic seafood spots.
Whether you are craving juicy sweet jumbo shrimp, a massive lobster dinner, or fresh clams, you will find it here. Grab a seat overlooking Eastchester Bay or Long Island Sound, and watch the seagulls and leisure sailboats off in the distance while you eat.
Yacht clubs, sailing, and a deep maritime legacy
This island isn’t just about eating; it has a serious shipbuilding history. During the mid-20th century, City Island was a massive hub for shipbuilders. In fact, many America’s Cup winning boats were built right in the local Nevins Boat Yard.
Today, that maritime spirit is kept alive by spots like the City Island Yacht Club, the Morris Yacht and Beach Club, and the Harlem Yacht Club. You can frequently catch university sailing teams practicing out on the water.
Want to dive deeper into the past? Check out the City Island Nautical Museum at 190 Fordham Street. It is housed in a historic 1897 school building and is packed with local maritime artifacts (open on weekend afternoons).
What to know before you go
City Island is easily accessible, but the journey there is half the fun. Biking through Pelham Bay Park is highly recommended on a sunny day. The din of the city slowly fades away as you pedal through the massive green space toward the water.
Once you arrive, keep an eye out for the wildlife. You might spot bufflehead ducks, great blue herons, or even the famous bright green monk parakeets that breed in the wild here.
Skip the expensive Hampton jitneys this summer. Just hop on your bike or take a drive up to the Bronx for your very own local seaside escape!
