HBO Max released the first clip from their upcoming Harry Potter series, and the internet had quite a lot to say about it.
Featuring NY native John Lithgow as Dumbledore (as well as other moguls of the NYC Broadway scene) the show adapts J.K. Rowling’s books, starting with Harry Potter and the Philosopher’s Stone.
HBO Max released an initial trailer in March, before hinting at the show’s first clip earlier this week. The sequence shows the students on their first night at Hogwarts, awe-struck as Dumbledore makes food magically appear across the long tables of the hall. It’s a scene many are familiar with, as it appears in Colombus’ iconic 2001 adaptation.
Fans of the Harry Potter universe immediately took to social media to dissect the scene, with some calling it “whimsyless” and “not quite right.” In particular, criticisms about lighting surfaced, with many disappointed by the lack of vibrancy and color.
A cast familiar to NYC
Unlike in the original film, which only featured British and Irish actors, this new adaptation will feature New Yorker John Lithgow as Dumbledore.
Born in Rochester, NY, the actor is no stranger to Broadway. With decades of stage credits and two Tony Awards on his belt, Lithgow is sure to leave his mark on this new cinematic production.

Many of the British cast members playing Hogwarts professors and Ministry officials are also Broadway veterans. Janet McTeer (Minerva McGonagall) is a Tony Award winner on Broadway for A Doll’s House, and Bertie Carvel (Cornelius Fudge) won a Tony for Ink.
Beyond these Broadway legends, The Harry Potter series stars Dominic McLaughlin as Harry Potter, Arabella Stanton as Hermione Granger, and Alastair Stout as Ron Weasley.
This holiday season, they will stand under the watchful eye of the Harry Potter fandom, along with plenty more seasoned and upcoming actors.
Step inside the Forbidden Forest
“Whimsical” or not, the new Harry Potter series has already been confirmed for a second season.
While waiting for the series to drop, New Yorkers can step inside Harry Potter’s Forbidden Forest in Westchester, featuring 4,000+ lights and life-sized creatures. The experience is open through December 13th just an hour from NYC, with tickets starting at $35.90.
Harry Potter™: A Forbidden Forest Experience
19 Nov 2026 17:30 + more dates
Franklin D. Roosevelt State Park
